How many listen to 2 channel music with their sub on?

Options
1235

Comments

  • leroyjr1
    leroyjr1 Posts: 8,785
    edited March 2011
    Options
    heiney9 wrote: »
    It's not always about the speakers.............the gear has a lot to do with it as well.

    I have heard bass out of my 1C's when watching a movie that I have never heard/felt listening to music...........I can reasonably deduce that's because much of recorded music just doesn't have this lower octave everyone swears those of us who don't have subs is missing.

    Just because a real instrument can go below 35Hz doesn't mean it's necessarily recorded at that level. Much of the processing in modern music uses techniques that restrict material below a certain frequency.

    Now that's not to say that a well done recording doesn't have these lower frequency's, what I'm saying is *most* music really doesn't play below about 30-32Hz...........now before everyone jumps on me.........I didn't say ALL MUSIC.

    If you are hearing these supposed lower frequencies (that aren't really part of the recording) then I would submit that in many cases the sub is coloring or boosting or accentuating those lowest frequencies.

    I have more bass than I ever thought possible in my room, with my gear. A sub would be overkill.

    H9

    Gear is very important, but speakers play the biggest part. I don't care what kind of gear you have if your speakers can't produce low end extension then they just can't.
  • heiney9
    heiney9 Posts: 25,724
    edited March 2011
    Options
    leroyjr1 wrote: »
    Gear is very important, but speakers play the biggest part. I don't care what kind of gear you have if your speakers can't produce low end extension then they just can't.

    I agree..........but most SDA's go low enough that, in my experience, a sub is not needed. Of course they need proper gear and set-up.

    H9
    "Appreciation of audio is a completely subjective human experience. Measurements can provide a measure of insight, but are no substitute for human judgment. Why are we looking to reduce a subjective experience to objective criteria anyway? The subtleties of music and audio reproduction are for those who appreciate it. Differentiation by numbers is for those who do not".--Nelson Pass Pass Labs XA25 | Galion TS P75 Pre | Holo Audio Cyan 2 Dac | MIT Shotgun S1 | Puritan Audio PSM136 Pwr Condtioner & Classic PC's | Legend L600 | Roon Nucleus 1 w/LPS - Tubes add soul!
  • jhw59
    jhw59 Posts: 348
    edited March 2011
    Options
    My Klipsch Heresys cut out around 60hz so a sub really helps so yes all the time for 2 channel.
  • quadzilla
    quadzilla Posts: 1,543
    edited March 2011
    Options
    aboroth00 wrote: »
    I didn't quite catch which subs you're using now; it wasn't referenced in this thread. I'm just curious that's all.

    But a DIY sub would pretty much blow away any competitors for the price. Only problem is: all the labor involved!

    Not just price, but something customized to my needs. The goal is to eventually get something that does work with the rest of my gear and blends transparently. Because, at no point did I say I was against subs, I've only said that, of the ones I've tried, I haven't like them, and that in my rooms using my rigs, I don't like subs for 2 channel.

    But if I can get, say, some TC Sounds 15s, or a couple of Epic 18s, maybe even 21s, in an IB, then things may change.

    As to what I have now, I finally settled on a pair of M&Ks, as they were the most musical, or the least non-musical, depending on your view.
    Turntable: Empire 208
    Arm: Rega 300
    Cart: Shelter 501 III
    Phono Pre: dsachs consulting
    Digital: Marantz SACD 30n
    Pre: Conrad Johnson ET3 SE
    Amp: Conrad Johnson Premier 350
    Cables: Cardas Neutral Reference
    Speakers: SDA 2.3TL, heavily modified
  • heiney9
    heiney9 Posts: 25,724
    edited March 2011
    Options
    Just to put things in perspective these are measured responses for the SDA 1C. Yes, measurements don't always correlate exactly with real world listening because of room variables, etc. But why would I need to add a sub when......

    ......The measured frequency response of the SDA 1C is 20Hz - 18Khz (+/-) 5dB now granted 5dB down at 20Hz is a noticeable roll off, but it's not that bad or completely beyond audibility or in a real sense tactile feeling.

    Bass distortion was phenominally low from 100Hz down to 25Hz @ 0.8% and only 3.2% @ 20Hz.......the lowest bass distortion ever measured up to that point.

    So tell me again, this is for you Phil :wink:, why am I missing something in my rig? So a normal sub will fill in below 20Hz? What musical recordings actually produce signals that low? Not instruments, but actual recorded music? Beside organ music which I am not a huge fan of?

    I realize some of the classical reference recordings most likely have very low frequency signals at times...........but again how many? What am I really missing? And ftr, I don't listen to classical.

    So again all us 2ch guys living in the past and don't have enough sense to get a sub because everyone *must* have one or they are missing something in their musical presentation. Please tell me how a sub will augment my system?

    H9
    "Appreciation of audio is a completely subjective human experience. Measurements can provide a measure of insight, but are no substitute for human judgment. Why are we looking to reduce a subjective experience to objective criteria anyway? The subtleties of music and audio reproduction are for those who appreciate it. Differentiation by numbers is for those who do not".--Nelson Pass Pass Labs XA25 | Galion TS P75 Pre | Holo Audio Cyan 2 Dac | MIT Shotgun S1 | Puritan Audio PSM136 Pwr Condtioner & Classic PC's | Legend L600 | Roon Nucleus 1 w/LPS - Tubes add soul!
  • JimAckley
    JimAckley Posts: 1,138
    edited March 2011
    Options
    quadzilla wrote: »
    Not just price, but something customized to my needs. The goal is to eventually get something that does work with the rest of my gear and blends transparently. Because, at no point did I say I was against subs, I've only said that, of the ones I've tried, I haven't like them, and that in my rooms using my rigs, I don't like subs for 2 channel.

    But if I can get, say, some TC Sounds 15s, or a couple of Epic 18s, maybe even 21s, in an IB, then things may change.

    As to what I have now, I finally settled on a pair of M&Ks, as they were the most musical, or the least non-musical, depending on your view.

    I'd definitely look into the TC Sounds drivers. I'm about to grab an LMS 5400and two VMP 18" passives. That setup is absolutely incredible, and the 5100 Pro as a solo unit, or coupled with passives, is even better for the average consumer. If you have the space, get a 5100 Pro and either port or passive it. If you've ever got some free time, I know a guy up in Sherman who's got the 5400 in a sealed enclosure, and it's breathtaking. We could roll up there sometime and listen to it if you want. I'll have mine all put together sometime this summer.
    - Computer Rig -
    YAΘIN MS-20L, polkaudio RT5

    - Main Rig -
    Pioneer SC-37, Overnight Sensations, Samsung 52" LCD

    - Currently In Progress -
    Curt Campbell's Uluwatu LCR, LMS Ultra Gjallarhorn, JBL W15GTi stereo subs, 2.1 entertainment system for the gf
  • pearsall001
    pearsall001 Posts: 5,400
    edited March 2011
    Options
    heiney9 wrote: »
    So tell me again, this is for you Phil :wink:, why am I missing something in my rig? So a normal sub will fill in below 20Hz? What musical recordings actually produce signals that low? Not instruments, but actual recorded music? Beside organ music which I am not a huge fan of?

    I realize some of the classical reference recordings most likely have very low frequency signals at times...........but again how many? What am I really missing? And ftr, I don't listen to classical.

    So again all us 2ch guys living in the past and don't have enough sense to get a sub because everyone *must* have one or they are missing something in their musical presentation. Please tell me how a sub will augment my system?

    H9

    Brock, I never meant to imply that you needed a sub...honestly you need two of those bad boys!!!! :smile: In chasing after that elusive 2% everything matters. :wink:
  • newrival
    newrival Posts: 2,016
    edited March 2011
    Options
    too funny
    design is where science and art break even.
  • comfortablycurt
    comfortablycurt Posts: 6,745
    edited March 2011
    Options
    All you guys with big SDA's! You don't need a sub!!

    We're all aware of that fact. ;) I don't think anyone here has implied that every system out there absolutely needs a sub, without question. Obviously some speakers are capable of digging down low enough to make the addition of a sub essentially insignificant. Just because your personal systems don't need them though, doesn't mean that no other serious 2 channel enthusiast could possibly use one successfully.

    Fact is, the majority of the speakers out there don't really have much in the way of real usable output below 35-40hz or so. For many people, digging down to 35-40 hz is plenty. Not for everyone though. I've found the addition of my relatively entry level sub to my rig has made a substantial improvement on the low end of my system. For a long time I refused to use it, because I heard a lot of you saying that subs in 2 channel rigs was just wrong. Then I tried hooking it up, and I'm never going back. My SDA 2A's have very respectable bass on their own...but they sound fathoms better with my sub crossed over at 50hz.

    Some of you seem to be too stuck in your own personal ways, and unwilling to accept that the personal tastes and requirements of someone else may be different. Some people simply like to have fuller bass. You can go ahead and say that having fuller bass is "coloring" the signal or changing it from the way it was originally intended to be listened to blah blah blah. Who cares? If those that are using subs are enjoying them, why should it matter to you? Let them enjoy them. Many MANY systems can benefit greatly from using subwoofers. There's absolutely nothing "wrong" or "improper" about using subs in a 2 channel rig, and the use of them in 2 channel rigs does not cause your rig to lose it's "2 channel" status.:rolleyes: On the flip side though, there is absolutely nothing wrong or improper about NOT using a sub(s). Many people don't need that extra bass extension or even want it. Many of you that are running big SDA's already have solid output down to 20ish HZ and for those of you who are...you obviously don't need a sub. I don't believe anyone is suggesting that you do. However, many of you are completely ruling out the possibility that it could in any way improve anything, and that's very counter productive to this hobby. Aren't you the ones always saying that the only way you can judge a component or setup is by listening to it, preferably in your own home? How many of you guys with the big SDA's have actually tried using subs? I know there are at least a few people on this board that are happily running subs with their big SRS's. Don't knock it if you haven't tried it. Discuss the possible merits/drawbacks to it...yes...but don't completely rule out the possibility that it could improve anything in any way...because that fact is, unless you've tried it...all you have is speculation.

    The results of this poll provide some kind of indication as to how many people actually ARE enjoying their 2 channel rigs with subs. I bet not all of the people who replied yes are running little bookshelf speakers either. I'm sure many of them are running supposed "full range" floorstanders...and have found their subs to make a very appreciable improvement. I'm but one example of the latter.
    The nirvana inducer-
    APC H10 Power Conditioner
    Marantz UD5005 universal player
    Parasound Halo P5 preamp
    Parasound HCA-1200II power amp
    PolkAudio LSi9's/PolkAudio SDA 2A's/PolkAudio Monitor 7A's
    Audioquest Speaker Cables and IC's
  • newrival
    newrival Posts: 2,016
    edited March 2011
    Options
    I have run a sub with my SRS's despite them having a lower f3 of 28Hz (nom.). While there was a definite benefit in the way of sub-bass reinforcement and weight, I was having room interaction issues that were beyond my ability to solve at the time and so it was relieved of its duty. Even the venerable 1.2tl's could benefit from a sub seeing as they, too, have a lower f3 of 27Hz. The 1c's are somewhere around 32Hz IIRC.

    Curt, as a "furthermore" to your post, I'd say that for some, the addition of a sub is akin to an admission that ones system is somehow lacking or inferior. The truth is that there are VERY few speakers out there that can't technically benefit from subwoofers. Hell, even the Wilson Audio SLAMM was designed with stereo external subs. But not everyone enjoys that sound, or at least feels that they would. As someone stated in this thread, there are those that love the sound of bass that others might call "anemic." As you pointed out, it's a preference, and we all have our own.
    design is where science and art break even.
  • heiney9
    heiney9 Posts: 25,724
    edited March 2011
    Options
    All you guys with big SDA's! You don't need a sub!!

    We're all aware of that fact. ;) I don't think anyone here has implied that every system out there absolutely needs a sub, without question.

    Actually yes, quite a few people did say that. :smile:

    No one has addressed my question about recorded music not having much content below about 32Hz. I still believe, based on listening to a lot of music, there are relatively few instances of recorded music hitting much below 32-35Hz. Sure there are examples, I'm sure of Classical and perhaps some live recordings, but on the whole there isn't that much. I get a lot more bass from the 1C's from movie soundtracks than music, so I know they are capable of more but the content just isn't there for most popular music.

    To me, as I stated before, if the musical content isn't there, then the sub is emphasizing the bass that you do seem to hear when using a sub. It's boosting the output at the same frequency that a full range floorstander is already producing.

    Subs are great for multi-channel music DVD's and movies because they are mastered to emphasize the lower bass, but I see little use for them in a properly set up 2 channel environment where your main speakers will play the lowest note in 99% of the music on cd.

    H9
    "Appreciation of audio is a completely subjective human experience. Measurements can provide a measure of insight, but are no substitute for human judgment. Why are we looking to reduce a subjective experience to objective criteria anyway? The subtleties of music and audio reproduction are for those who appreciate it. Differentiation by numbers is for those who do not".--Nelson Pass Pass Labs XA25 | Galion TS P75 Pre | Holo Audio Cyan 2 Dac | MIT Shotgun S1 | Puritan Audio PSM136 Pwr Condtioner & Classic PC's | Legend L600 | Roon Nucleus 1 w/LPS - Tubes add soul!
  • heiney9
    heiney9 Posts: 25,724
    edited March 2011
    Options
    The word sub-woofer is actually a misnomer. A sub should not play frequencies above about 30Hz, but they do and many cheaper subs can't even play much below that.

    A sub-woofer should play only at frequencies below that of a floorstander. The really, really expensive subs do, but most don't. And these arbitrary crossover points built into AVR's aren't the best way to integrate a sub unless your main speakers are really incapable of producing lower bass.

    So perhaps if you had a very sophisticated x-over and a really, really nice *true* subwoofer there could be some advantages. I choose not the invest the money (because it could be quite costly to do it correctly) or time into this area because, for me personally, the possible advantages just aren't worth it and I'm not convinced most recorded music has much content below what my floorstanders produce.

    I think it's funny some of the same guys unwilling to use tone controls are A-OK with using a sub that colors the sound so much.

    H9
    "Appreciation of audio is a completely subjective human experience. Measurements can provide a measure of insight, but are no substitute for human judgment. Why are we looking to reduce a subjective experience to objective criteria anyway? The subtleties of music and audio reproduction are for those who appreciate it. Differentiation by numbers is for those who do not".--Nelson Pass Pass Labs XA25 | Galion TS P75 Pre | Holo Audio Cyan 2 Dac | MIT Shotgun S1 | Puritan Audio PSM136 Pwr Condtioner & Classic PC's | Legend L600 | Roon Nucleus 1 w/LPS - Tubes add soul!
  • leroyjr1
    leroyjr1 Posts: 8,785
    edited March 2011
    Options
    I'd like to add when I owned the bigger SRS's and dual MP4K subs the SRS's hit just as hard and dug just as deep as the subs, so they wasn't needed for 2 channel and I was satisfied. Other speakers that I've owned definitely needed them. I think with a good musical sub like a JL Fathom or Velodyne DD series it'll be a big plus to a 2 channel system. I'm very interested in seeing what subs people were using in there 2 channel system that didn't like them or the people that believe 2 channel shouldn't consist of a sub have they ever tried using one? The bigger 15" PR sda's are the only speakers I've heard that didnt need any lower end reinforcement, all the others did IMO.
  • heiney9
    heiney9 Posts: 25,724
    edited March 2011
    Options
    heiney9 wrote: »

    I think it's funny some of the same guys unwilling to use tone controls are A-OK with using a sub that colors the sound so much.

    H9

    Since I can't edit..........let me clarify. I should have said:

    I think it's funny some of the same guys unwilling to use tone controls are A-OK with using a sub that *could* color the sound so much.

    H9
    "Appreciation of audio is a completely subjective human experience. Measurements can provide a measure of insight, but are no substitute for human judgment. Why are we looking to reduce a subjective experience to objective criteria anyway? The subtleties of music and audio reproduction are for those who appreciate it. Differentiation by numbers is for those who do not".--Nelson Pass Pass Labs XA25 | Galion TS P75 Pre | Holo Audio Cyan 2 Dac | MIT Shotgun S1 | Puritan Audio PSM136 Pwr Condtioner & Classic PC's | Legend L600 | Roon Nucleus 1 w/LPS - Tubes add soul!
  • heiney9
    heiney9 Posts: 25,724
    edited March 2011
    Options
    leroyjr1 wrote: »
    I'd like to add when I owned the bigger SRS's and dual MP4K subs the SRS's hit just as hard and dug just as deep as the subs, so they wasn't needed for 2 channel and I was satisfied. Other speakers that I've owned definitely needed them. I think with a good musical sub like a JL Fathom or Velodyne DD series it'll be a big plus to a 2 channel system. I'm very interested in seeing what subs people were using in there 2 channel system that didn't like them or the people that believe 2 channel shouldn't consist of a sub have they ever tried using one? The bigger 15" PR sda's are the only speakers I've heard that didnt need any lower end reinforcement, all the others did IMO.

    You do realize the measured freq response for SRS's and 1C's don't vary by much. Again set-up and room, gear, etc play a part in it. Also measurements don't tell you everything, but they aren't that far off atleast according to the measurements done by Stereo Review in the 80's. Do the SRS's have more bass at certain freq, most likely.....again not that far off.

    1C's (25-18,000 Khz) +/- 5dB

    SRS (24-20,000 Khz) +/- 4dB
    "Appreciation of audio is a completely subjective human experience. Measurements can provide a measure of insight, but are no substitute for human judgment. Why are we looking to reduce a subjective experience to objective criteria anyway? The subtleties of music and audio reproduction are for those who appreciate it. Differentiation by numbers is for those who do not".--Nelson Pass Pass Labs XA25 | Galion TS P75 Pre | Holo Audio Cyan 2 Dac | MIT Shotgun S1 | Puritan Audio PSM136 Pwr Condtioner & Classic PC's | Legend L600 | Roon Nucleus 1 w/LPS - Tubes add soul!
  • heiney9
    heiney9 Posts: 25,724
    edited March 2011
    Options
    I still want to know where this "musical content" is coming from for all you sub owners who sware the music digs deeper when using a sub with full range speakers that are capable of producing the same content?

    I don't want a singular, specific example here and there, because I know there are exceptions out there of recordings that have lower bass content. No one has convinced me, nor have I heard of an example where a sub in full range 2ch system isn't slightly enhancing, coloring or boosting certain bass frequencies to give the allusion of extra or lower bass response. That's exactly why I didn't like the LSi 9's. Everyone says the bass is prodigous, it just has an upper mid-bass hump that sounds good until you realize how much it colors the music. Nothing wrong if that tone suits your listening tastes. For me, after awhile, it sounded to unnatural.

    H9
    "Appreciation of audio is a completely subjective human experience. Measurements can provide a measure of insight, but are no substitute for human judgment. Why are we looking to reduce a subjective experience to objective criteria anyway? The subtleties of music and audio reproduction are for those who appreciate it. Differentiation by numbers is for those who do not".--Nelson Pass Pass Labs XA25 | Galion TS P75 Pre | Holo Audio Cyan 2 Dac | MIT Shotgun S1 | Puritan Audio PSM136 Pwr Condtioner & Classic PC's | Legend L600 | Roon Nucleus 1 w/LPS - Tubes add soul!
  • dorourke07
    dorourke07 Posts: 298
    edited March 2011
    Options
    The sub is crossed at 35hz and the gain is less than half. Just enough to cover the bottom end if needed. The 9's are the big players.
    Mains - LSi9's
    Center - LSiC
    Surround - pair of TL3's
    Amplification - Parasound 2125
    AVR - Onkyo 706
    CD/SACD - Onkyo DV-SP506
    SUB - MartinLogan Abyss
    55" Panasonic Viera TC-P55GT30 3D
    Bluray - DMP-BDT310 Panasonic
  • heiney9
    heiney9 Posts: 25,724
    edited March 2011
    Options
    I have heard one system with dual subs that impressed me. In a very, very large lower level of a friends home. He had Revel Ultima Salon's for mains, dual Veodyne DD15's (the expensive ones, $3K a piece, IIRC). Mark Levinson mono's and a full blown Lexicon processor.

    It was geared for HT based on the processor and center speaker which was a mathcing Revel with it's own Levinson mono. It's sounded incredible.............it should have since there was about $35-40K worth of gear there and it was done properly, still HT though.

    The same friend has the same speakers (minus the center), same Levinson amps all run by Meridian gear in a 2ch dedicated room.............guess what no subs this time!!! And it sounds even better.

    H9
    "Appreciation of audio is a completely subjective human experience. Measurements can provide a measure of insight, but are no substitute for human judgment. Why are we looking to reduce a subjective experience to objective criteria anyway? The subtleties of music and audio reproduction are for those who appreciate it. Differentiation by numbers is for those who do not".--Nelson Pass Pass Labs XA25 | Galion TS P75 Pre | Holo Audio Cyan 2 Dac | MIT Shotgun S1 | Puritan Audio PSM136 Pwr Condtioner & Classic PC's | Legend L600 | Roon Nucleus 1 w/LPS - Tubes add soul!
  • thesurfer
    thesurfer Posts: 574
    edited March 2011
    Options
    heiney9 wrote: »
    Since I can't edit..........let me clarify. I should have said:

    I think it's funny some of the same guys unwilling to use tone controls are A-OK with using a sub that *could* color the sound so much.

    H9
    Thats what ive been saying all along,, if the music does not go that low,, your simply boosting the bass effect, in other words, another form of coloring the bass effect, Ive been to many stadium concerts, and sat up front,, never, once felt the bass,,, To me it has alot to do with the music,, also, alot of folks have a differant OP, to what coloring music is,, The same guys that say using Tone controls, EQ,s and any form of boosting, Is for the Lost,,, yet, in most cases,, there doing the same, with a Sub,,
    Not an Audiophile, just a dude who loves music, and decent gear to hear it with.
  • heiney9
    heiney9 Posts: 25,724
    edited March 2011
    Options
    I'm not saying yay or nay on the use of a sub.........do what makes you happy, but to integrate a sub properly into a 2ch system it takes some effort and a a great deal of expense (relatively speaking) to do it right and then, in my case, the payoff isn't worth it because my main speakers do just a good a job on their own.

    Those who are saying it's a must need to dial it back a bit, because you all should know there are no absolutes in this hobby.

    I'm not saying I'm right and your wrong, but I don't think you (those using subs in 2ch w/full range speakers) should say I'm wrong and you're right. In the big picture there is no specified way to participate in this hobby. I've given my reasons and others have given theirs.

    H9
    "Appreciation of audio is a completely subjective human experience. Measurements can provide a measure of insight, but are no substitute for human judgment. Why are we looking to reduce a subjective experience to objective criteria anyway? The subtleties of music and audio reproduction are for those who appreciate it. Differentiation by numbers is for those who do not".--Nelson Pass Pass Labs XA25 | Galion TS P75 Pre | Holo Audio Cyan 2 Dac | MIT Shotgun S1 | Puritan Audio PSM136 Pwr Condtioner & Classic PC's | Legend L600 | Roon Nucleus 1 w/LPS - Tubes add soul!
  • thesurfer
    thesurfer Posts: 574
    edited March 2011
    Options
    As said before, to each there own, know ones right, or wrong,, Its all a matter of taste, and what one likes,,, To me, know one has the right to say you should, or shouldnt do this or that, I know alot of guys that have high end stuff, and dont need a sub, but use it in 2 channel, simply because of the effects, of the bass responce, They admit there boosting the low end, cause thats what they like, There bassheads,, and good for them, just not my cup of tea,,
    Not an Audiophile, just a dude who loves music, and decent gear to hear it with.
  • polkfan38
    polkfan38 Posts: 360
    edited March 2011
    Options
    I guess if I had the cash, two large towers would be my way to go. However, on a budget, a couple of decent bookshelves and a sub would do the trick. Like many have said, it's all personal preference. If done right, either would work. I am a fanboy of large speakers. Even at low volumes, they just sound better to me. The way they fill a room with sound.
    Things are more like they are now than they ever will be!
  • cfrizz
    cfrizz Posts: 13,415
    edited March 2011
    Options
    This works both ways H9. Can you provide proof that the recorded music doesn't have content below 32Hz?:smile:

    heiney9 wrote: »
    Actually yes, quite a few people did say that. :smile:

    No one has addressed my question about recorded music not having much content below about 32Hz. I still believe, based on listening to a lot of music, there are relatively few instances of recorded music hitting much below 32-35Hz. Sure there are examples, I'm sure of Classical and perhaps some live recordings, but on the whole there isn't that much. I get a lot more bass from the 1C's from movie soundtracks than music, so I know they are capable of more but the content just isn't there for most popular music.

    To me, as I stated before, if the musical content isn't there, then the sub is emphasizing the bass that you do seem to hear when using a sub. It's boosting the output at the same frequency that a full range floorstander is already producing.

    Subs are great for multi-channel music DVD's and movies because they are mastered to emphasize the lower bass, but I see little use for them in a properly set up 2 channel environment where your main speakers will play the lowest note in 99% of the music on cd.

    H9
    heiney9 wrote: »
    I still want to know where this "musical content" is coming from for all you sub owners who sware the music digs deeper when using a sub with full range speakers that are capable of producing the same content?I don't want a singular, specific example here and there, because I know there are exceptions out there of recordings that have lower bass content. No one has convinced me, nor have I heard of an example where a sub in full range 2ch system isn't slightly enhancing, coloring or boosting certain bass frequencies to give the allusion of extra or lower bass response. That's exactly why I didn't like the LSi 9's. Everyone says the bass is prodigous, it just has an upper mid-bass hump that sounds good until you realize how much it colors the music. Nothing wrong if that tone suits your listening tastes. For me, after awhile, it sounded to unnatural.

    H9
    Marantz AV-7705 PrePro, Classé 5 channel 200wpc Amp, Oppo 103 BluRay, Rotel RCD-1072 CDP, Sony XBR-49X800E TV, Polk S60 Main Speakers, Polk ES30 Center Channel, Polk S15 Surround Speakers SVS SB12-NSD x2
  • heiney9
    heiney9 Posts: 25,724
    edited March 2011
    Options
    The proof is on those who say everyone needs a sub in their rig because we are missing low end content. I am asking those that contend a sub is needed no matter what, to show me the music they listen to actually has content below 35Hz.

    Like I said, when I watch dynamic movies I can feel a lot more bass than when listening to music. Sometimes the low bass tickles my toes and envelopes the room, but not too much on music, if ever. Movies are just played in 2.0 Dolby, no LFE track or other Dolby decoding that adds even more low end content, by design I might add.

    H9

    P.s. When changing amps my bass increased more than I thought possible (both in texture and content and depth), so there is definitely a gear element in the mix as well. So throw in gear, room, musical content, full range speakers, set-up, etc.....should I go on, and you can see there is really no singular answer for all situations.
    "Appreciation of audio is a completely subjective human experience. Measurements can provide a measure of insight, but are no substitute for human judgment. Why are we looking to reduce a subjective experience to objective criteria anyway? The subtleties of music and audio reproduction are for those who appreciate it. Differentiation by numbers is for those who do not".--Nelson Pass Pass Labs XA25 | Galion TS P75 Pre | Holo Audio Cyan 2 Dac | MIT Shotgun S1 | Puritan Audio PSM136 Pwr Condtioner & Classic PC's | Legend L600 | Roon Nucleus 1 w/LPS - Tubes add soul!
  • polktiger
    polktiger Posts: 556
    edited March 2011
    Options
    I will admit, I haven't read this whole thread, but similar to H9's comments...I don't use a sub IF I am listening to speakers that are actually full range. Most recently in 2 channel I was flip flopping between SDA 1Bs and some Totem Winds and there was no need for me to use a sub as both of those will get pretty deep.

    It seems some discussion is about whether music has content down below 40 hz. It certainly depends on what you listen to. Hearing a lot of subs, a many mainstream subs poor job even getting below 40hz, so you have to have a pretty good sub to begin with if you are worried about sound in that range.

    Something similar to this may have been posted earlier, but the attached link gives some idea of "how deep" some instruments go. You will see, there aren't but a couple that can get under 40. Obviously, electronic music can probably produce any frequency desired.

    http://www.psbspeakers.com/audio-topics/The-Frequencies-of-Music
  • heiney9
    heiney9 Posts: 25,724
    edited March 2011
    Options
    polktiger wrote: »

    Something similar to this may have been posted earlier, but the attached link gives some idea of "how deep" some instruments go. You will see, there aren't but a couple that can get under 40. Obviously, electronic music can probably produce any frequency desired.

    http://www.psbspeakers.com/audio-topics/The-Frequencies-of-Music

    I understand a free air instrument can produce sounds below 35Hz, but my question is when music is being recorded, mixed, mastered, etc much of the content that makes it on the actual recording is constrained to a certain range of frequencies. Of course there are some, for lack of a better word "audiophile", recordings that don't necessarily use the same standard recording process.

    I have a wonderful live recording of Stanley Clark, Larry Carlton, Billy Cobham, Deron Johnson and Najee - Live at the Greek that is one of the most dynamic recordings I own and the bass goes deeeeeeeep. I can literally shake the foundation a higher levels. Much deeper than a typical recording of the same type of instruments in the same setting. So I know these types of recordings out there..........and still my system produces lots of bass when asked to by the recording.

    H9
    "Appreciation of audio is a completely subjective human experience. Measurements can provide a measure of insight, but are no substitute for human judgment. Why are we looking to reduce a subjective experience to objective criteria anyway? The subtleties of music and audio reproduction are for those who appreciate it. Differentiation by numbers is for those who do not".--Nelson Pass Pass Labs XA25 | Galion TS P75 Pre | Holo Audio Cyan 2 Dac | MIT Shotgun S1 | Puritan Audio PSM136 Pwr Condtioner & Classic PC's | Legend L600 | Roon Nucleus 1 w/LPS - Tubes add soul!
  • thesurfer
    thesurfer Posts: 574
    edited March 2011
    Options
    Ive also noticed, that alot of music, that was remastered to the cd format, was somehow thinner sounding,, as if they cleaned alot of the bass, from the analog, master recording,, as stated, you have to consider the type of music,, and its format,,and how it got mixed to begin with,
    Not an Audiophile, just a dude who loves music, and decent gear to hear it with.
  • quadzilla
    quadzilla Posts: 1,543
    edited March 2011
    Options
    cfrizz wrote: »
    This works both ways H9. Can you provide proof that the recorded music doesn't have content below 32Hz?:smile:

    It's easy enought to prove.... name a half dozen or dozen tracts, and me or someone can run them through a spectrum analyzer and see what comes out. It's really not that hard to show.

    Or you can just grab audacity (free) which includes a spectrum plot analyzer and see for yourself.
    Turntable: Empire 208
    Arm: Rega 300
    Cart: Shelter 501 III
    Phono Pre: dsachs consulting
    Digital: Marantz SACD 30n
    Pre: Conrad Johnson ET3 SE
    Amp: Conrad Johnson Premier 350
    Cables: Cardas Neutral Reference
    Speakers: SDA 2.3TL, heavily modified
  • F1nut
    F1nut Posts: 52,406
    edited March 2011
    Options
    I stopped by MLS's earlier tonight. His 2BTL's do not need a sub.
  • heiney9
    heiney9 Posts: 25,724
    edited March 2011
    Options
    F1nut wrote: »
    I stopped by MLS's earlier tonight. His 2BTL's do not need a sub.

    No Jesse, everyone needs a sub.......we are missing important musical content :wink:

    H9
    "Appreciation of audio is a completely subjective human experience. Measurements can provide a measure of insight, but are no substitute for human judgment. Why are we looking to reduce a subjective experience to objective criteria anyway? The subtleties of music and audio reproduction are for those who appreciate it. Differentiation by numbers is for those who do not".--Nelson Pass Pass Labs XA25 | Galion TS P75 Pre | Holo Audio Cyan 2 Dac | MIT Shotgun S1 | Puritan Audio PSM136 Pwr Condtioner & Classic PC's | Legend L600 | Roon Nucleus 1 w/LPS - Tubes add soul!