You are a Hall of Fame Voter
Comments
-
Joe -
Of the ones you didn't highlight...I firmly believe a strong case can be made for all.
My daughter wrote a term paper for her "History of Rock & Roll" class she took in college making the case for Buffett to be included in the RRHOF (with some research assistance from her dad). While one may not be a fan...there is compelling data when one takes the loosely structured criteria of the HOF and applies it to Buffett. His influence on the R&R music scene is substantial. BTW…She got an A on the paper.
Rundgren's influence has been considerable on both sides of the microphone. Performer, writer, producer, innovator. He has been a stong influence in the work of quite a few artist (several on the list of should be RRHOFers). Maybe no ONE aspect gets him in...but the body of work should IMO.
Toto - If you look at the credentials of those who passed through the band and the success they had in what was a "dark era" for music (late 70's early 80's) Toto certainly deserves some consideration IMO. Maybe they don't get the nod because of the variations that the band went through. They were accomplished studio musicians who got together and made some pretty good music. Maybe the fact none of them were superstars in their own right limits their chances.
Kate Bush - Never had the success or influence here as she did in Great Brittan which is probably her downfall. She is one of the most successful British female artists. She has an unusual (but no less incredible) voice, with tremendous range. I like her work as an artist, but she is very accomplished as a writer and producer. A bit of an innovator as well. David Gilmore and Peter Gabriel recognized her talent and sing her praises…and that speaks volumes to me. Alas her lack of a strong US presence and her eclectic style will probably keep her out.
Steve, I always liked Buffett & Rundgren. I have a couple of LPs from both and enjoy their music. I just didn't know about their influences. I never did consider either Rock & Roll though.
Toto, I never was a fan but that's not to say they don't have a dog in the HoF fight.
I never heard of Kate Bush. I'll be sure when looking into some music purchases to check her out.
Great to hear about your daughter's 'A' !:)
