Ken.....

TroyD

I wanted to get your thoughts on some of the older planar speakers, ie Maggie I,II,III's , KLH 9's as well as maybe some of the current ones, newer Maggies, Apogee's etc....

I really want to dabble with planars and would be interested in your thoughts especially since some of the older Maggies can be found pretty reasonable.

BDT

RuSsMaN

KLH9's were electrostats, were they not?

-Russ

TroyD

yeah, but you know what I'm driving at, I should have been more specific. Planars, electrostats....non-box speakers.

BDT

RuSsMaN

Oh, I thought you said 'planar' speakers in your first post. Did'nt realize we were talking 'non-box' speakers. Hell, non-box changes everything....

Cheers,
Laughing Russ

Look at me, jackin your post up.....WAAAAAAAAAAAAAa

madmax

Don't they get damaged during shipment?
madmax

Ron-P

Nah, I'm sure they box'em up:)

Peace Out~:D

KennethSwauger

Hello Troy,
To my way of thinking speakers like the ones you've listed are a double edged sword. They offer definite advantages, but require careful considerations in order to elicit the best performance. The most important consideration is the fact that these speakers produce as much sound from the rear of the speaker as the front. Since this information is opposite in polarity to the front sounds it has to be dealt with to prevent cancellation. However, you need some of this rearward directed information to reach the listener to add to the "openness" and "three dimensionality" of the speakers. So, my point is that the room and the placement, of the speaker, in the room become an equal partner to the speaker itself. You should consider some kind of sound absorption material placed behind the speakers and then be prepared to move them forward and backward to get the balance between rear sound wave and front sound wave. Also they tend to be very equipment specific, meaning the final sound of the system is very much dependant upon what's powering them. Electrostatic speakers usually have a low impedance point at higher frequencies, sometimes as low as 1.5 ohms at 8 or 9 kHz. This low impedance can present a capacitive load to the amplifier and you have to be sure that the amplifier is going to be happy with this kind of load characteristic. The non-electrostatic panel speakers, such as the Magnaplaners, are going to have a different load characteristic and I'm not familiar enough to give advice there. But understand that the electronics driving the speakers is going to be more defining than another moving coil type speaker (such as the Polks). It's kind of like buying a British sports car, as long as you know what you're in for and find that part of the "charm", then no problem.
Take care, Ken

TroyD

thanks Ken.....

the rest of you yo-yo's......lick me

BDT