Toshiba HD-A2 VS Marantz DV-8300

Options
Posts: 1,860
edited June 2007 in Electronics
I am doing a A/B comparison using Batman Begins on DVD, then Batman Begins on HD-DVD compared to the same on DVD on the DV-8300...I am using Signal Component cables on the DV-8300, and a NX? (don't remember, it was free) HDMI cable for video on the HD-A2...Both are using Signal Analog II's for sound....I am running 2ch. with a Sunfire Super Junior...

My first impression of the HD-A2 is a little salty...I thought the DV-8300 had a long load time...This thing takes about 25-30 seconds longer to load a normal DVD...I attribute this to the HD-A2 needing to ID the format...Although the DV-8300 is a universal player, the load times are within a few seconds of each other...Eh, semantics....

While playing a normal DVD on the A2, the picture is a little more crisp due to the upscaling, but the sound is somewhat veiled compared to the DV-8300...Basically, whatever I gained in picture quality, I lost in sound quality...IMO, unless you plan on buying HD format from now on out, I wouldn't do it...

Now on to the HD-DVD.....There is a noticeable difference in picture quality, everything is much more crisp and the colors are more vibrant as well..The sound is better than a normal DVD, but still not quite up to par with the DV-8300 IMO....I am not surprised by the lack of audio quality, I am comparing a $1800 MSRP DVD player to a base HD-DVD player....I still thought it would be in the neighborhood somewhere....

Overall, I wouldn't buy this player if it cost me more than $99....The picture is nice, but I will still be watching DVDs on the DV-8300 for a while.....Maybe after the technology progresses farther, the SQ will get to the same point, maybe beyond the Marantz.....
Post edited by Bill Ayotte on

Comments

  • Posts: 697
    edited June 2007
    I think the HD-XA1 or XA2 would be more of a fair comparison. I don't own the XA2 yet, but for the XA1, there is a tremendous difference in sound between using analog and any of the digital connections which I found HDMI to be the best of those.

    Before installing the A2 in my fathers rig, I tried it in mine and there was no comparison in sound. Hands down, the XA1 beats it and I would assume the XA2 would as well.
  • Posts: 1,860
    edited June 2007
    Well, after watching a few movies through it and playing some music for **** and giggles, the sound has improved quite a bit.....Not quite on the level of the Marantz, but it is getting better...There is a lot more detail now.....Not a musical player, but I really didn't expect it to be....Sounds, eh, ok though....I've heard worse.....Anybody in the market for a nice DVD/HD-DVD player should check this one out, it up-converts well, and HD-DVDs are pretty spectacular PQ wise...Even if HD-DVD loses the format war, you have a nice player....The damn startup time still kills me though....

Welcome!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Welcome!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.