Axiom M3ti vs Strata Mini (vs Martin Logan Summit).... a 3rd party account

Joey_V
Joey_V Posts: 8,552
edited December 2006 in 2 Channel Audio
Introduction:
My audiophile friend came by, we met on HeadFi.org an audiophile community consisting of mainly headphone fanatics, and brought his trusty Axiom M3ti that he has been very happy with since he got them a year or 2 ago. We unpacked his M3ti and tried several spots before we came to the agreement to place the M3ti inside the Strata Mini infront of the Martin Logans.... we didnt want to place the M3ti too far apart.

We put the M3ti's on a 31" stand to align the tweeters up to the same level as the Minis and we pulled the listening chair back to form the "equilateral triangle" of critical listening. We dimmed the lights and listened...

At first, tried out his $30 Sonic T-Amp for fun. As you can see by the pictures, it's a nifty little device, but wasnt impressive to me at all. Too thin, too diffuse, and easily distorted especially with the Minis at about 80-85db of listening volume. Ok for a $30 product, but worth a serious look? Nah.

Matt was quick to ask me to hook up the big boys and toss the "toy" aside... referring to his T-Amp. So we did.

We hooked up the Squeezebox3 to the Cary SLP-98L Tube preamplifier and into the Plinius SA102 Class A amplifier... readily plugged into either the Axiom M3ti or the Strata Mini.

We demoed 4 songs total... we went from the Axiom M3ti then to the Strata Mini and then to the Axiom M3ti and then back to the Strata Mini... rinse and repeat PER SONG (x4).

The song selections:
1. Pennies from Heaven - Louis Prima
2. Sleighride - Ella Fitzgerald
3. Mr. Big To Be With You - Extreme
4. Keys to the Highway - BB King and Eric Clapton

Initially, I listened to both speakers and made sure they were aligned and properly positioned. I made sure each pair was imaging well and had proper staging. I manned all the switching and Matt stayed in the chair, thereafter.

Matt's Comments:
1. Pennies from Heaven:
Axiom
- "No grit in the sound, clean."
- "Background singers were piercing."
Mini
- "There was grit, Louis' voice was gritty... in a good way. The Axioms had barely any grit, it was there, but it wasnt noticeable. The Minis were more resolving of this hidden detail."
- "Tonality of the trumpet was better than the Axioms could resolve, in terms of tonality. Seemed to be more real."
- "The background singers did not have that slight metallic quality of the Axioms... very natural sounding even in the upper registers."

2. Sleighride - Ella Fitzgerald
Axiom
- "Metallic, slightly grating at times."
- "Sounded clean overall."
- "Trumpet did not remove itself from the speaker, slight boxiness was detected."
Mini
- "Laid back, maybe a little too laid back."
- "Trupmet was to the inside right of the Mini (R) speaker. Very cool effect."
- "Preferred Mini in this track, but not as much as I did on the first track... lesser of a lead, I'm impressed by the Axioms."

3. Mr Big to be with You - Extreme
Axiom
- "Boxed in imaging, no lateral soundstage outside both speakers."
- "Good center image, probably just as good as the Minis in terms of the lead singer."
- "Good depth and background vocals."
- "Very nicely renditioned lead singer."
- "More calculated sound, vs the Mini's musical sound."
Mini
- "Imaged well beyond the outside lateral borders of the speakers.
- "Tonality of the background singers was better than the Axioms presented."
- "Similar lead singer... well done by the Axioms!"
- "Minis was more musical, more organic. Better overall. Man, that was an awesome track, Joey! I want that one! Burn it!"
4. Keys to the Highway - BB King
Axioms
- "Eric Clapton was a little too bright, didnt sound realistic.
- "No drums were resolved by the Axioms whatsoever, I couldnt see it on the stage at all."
- "Guitar was piercing, not realistic."
- "Imaging wasnt solid on this one.. not sure if it was biased to the Right or the Center."
Minis
- "Drums were lifelike, so much easier for me to see on the stage."
- "BB King's voice was far more realistic, very gritty, very dynamic and deep in certain parts... very real."
- "BB King's guitar solo was realistic and was very well done. I've had this CD for some time and I've never heard it done as well as the Minis did them just now. That was truly the best demo song of the night, I want the Minis now! Very impressed with your selection of songs, Joey!"

My (Joey's) thoughts:
First off, I want to say that it was a great opportunity having Matt over at my place today! It was certainly great having an audiophile with atleast as much (if not more) dedication to this hobby of ours as I do, over for a listening session. Matt is a very critical listener, and I wouldnt be surprised if he has better ears than I do.

It was great seeing the Axioms again... one look at the M3ti and the memories of my black M22ti came rushing back. The cabinet, the asymmetric walls, the vortex port, the titanium tweeter, the aluminum woofer... it was as if the Axiom M22ti never left my room. It wasnt long before the Axiom and I were reacquainted.

My impressions of the Axiom M3ti are very favorable. First, I will say that they image wonderfully. The center image is on par with speakers that are far more expensive, most definitely. It had body and soul in the vocal reproduction. Vocal imaging was good, and vocal focus was definitely good through my system of preamps and amps. The midrange was clean and it came through clearly. The bass was tight, with nary the hint of bloat. I did not fault the Axioms for not reproducting bass as extended as the Minis, I listened mainly for coherence in the midrange and up, which by the way, the Axioms were quite coherent in.

The Mini, however, is a different animal. The Mini is more musical, better at resolving, better at staging, better at being box-less than the Axioms. I felt that the Minis were more, shall we say, "organic" sounding whereas the Axioms were more "clinical" sounding. Hard to explain, but if you were in my room with us, you'd understand. Irregardless of bass, the Mini had a better and more coherent midrange and treble.

HOWEVER, during the listening session, there were times when I felt that the Axiom M3ti were right on par with the Minis in terms of resolution and transparency, but the M3 lacked that last bit of realism that was instilled into almost every detail reproduced.

There is detail, and then there's realistic detail... probably the best way I could put it in words.

The Axioms were very good in their own right. I certainly have a lot of respect for the Axioms and what they can do at their pricepoint. They are certainly solid speakers sonically.

Conclusion:
The Minis are $1600 while the Axioms barely tip the scale at $300. The price discrepancy is large, but was it worth it? According to Matt, yes it was. He is getting a pair of the Strata Minis and moving his Axiom M3ti to bedroom duty with his upcoming Sonos system.
Magico M2, JL113v2x2, EMM, ARC Ref 10 Line, ARC Ref 10 Phono, VPIx2, Lyra Etna, Airtight Opus1, Boulder, AQ Wel&Wild, SRA Scuttle Rack, BlueSound+LPS, Thorens 124DD+124SPU, Sennheiser, Metaxas R2R
Post edited by Joey_V on

Comments

  • Joey_V
    Joey_V Posts: 8,552
    edited December 2006
    Sidebar:
    I didnt want to muddy up the playing field by including the Martin Logan Summits in a 3-way shootout. Matt came by to specifically listen to the Minis vs the M3ti and playing the Summits, to me, would be detrimental to his listening session as it would add another factor to consider in determining overall value of each of the speakers he was auditioning.

    But in the end, Matt requested that I play 2 songs on the ML Summits before I had to leave for dinner. Reluctantly, I said, OK.

    So I plugged in the ML Summits... and let 2 songs play. The first song was BB King's Keys to the Highway and the second song was Extreme's Mr Big to be with You. I stood behind Matt while he sat in his chair... we were embraced by luscious music. A few minutes later, I turned on the lights, the songs had ended.... and I asked him what he thought.

    He asked for the Minis to be plugged in again and we listened to the same 2 songs on the Minis. Lights off while the music played, and Matt closed his eyes and drifted to the Mini's version of this acoustic landscape. The 2 songs ended, we played it one last time on the Martin Logan Summits. Lights off, 2 songs, lights on.

    "Well?" I asked, "... and dont sugar coat it."

    Matt:
    - "Absolutely amazing centerfill. The Summits' centerstage had so much more information than the Minis. The imaging on the Summits were very very much tighter than on the Minis, listening to the Minis right after the Summits made me realize how "non-imaged" the Minis are. The vocals arent on the same level of focus. The lead singer was never as controlled on the Minis as he was on the ML Summits. The guitar solo was far more pronounced. Everything was much more realistic, when I didnt think it was possible to exceed the realism presented by the Minis. The staging was more accurate, the guitar was always 3 feet tall and the vocals were always 5 feet tall or so."

    "The initial drum strikes sounded so much more real than even on the Minis, there was no comparison! The staging is better, there is absolutely no boxiness to it. By comparison, the Minis is more boxed in by a large margin."

    "The Summits were truly mind blowing. Joey, I will tell you, I was just at Glenn Poor, the high end esoteric dealer in Chicago, and I listened to their $150,000 super system with the $50,000 Wilson Maxx2.... and your ML Summits are better to my ears. You have the best system I have ever heard."

    "And considering the fact that the Logans had the worst placement of the 3, being too close inside and too close to the front wall, it's scary to know that the Summits can get better! We're only scratching the surface..."

    "If you get a better DAC, it'd be sick!"

    "Mind blowing. Absolutely mind blowing... I dont know what else to say. I never heard anything near that level of reproduction, period."


    Pictures:
    Setting up the systems...
    DSC00939.jpg
    DSC00938.jpg
    DSC00940.jpg
    DSC00941.jpg

    The Sonic T-Amp... so cute!
    DSC00943.jpg

    The Cary SLP-98L Tube preamplifer:
    DSC00955.jpg
    DSC00961.jpg
    DSC00948.jpg
    DSC00949.jpg
    DSC00947.jpg

    The Plinius SA102 Class A SS amplifier:
    DSC00789.jpg
    DSC00781.jpg
    DSC00778.jpg

    Speakers...
    DSC00669.jpg
    DSC00872.jpg
    DSC00942.jpg
    Magico M2, JL113v2x2, EMM, ARC Ref 10 Line, ARC Ref 10 Phono, VPIx2, Lyra Etna, Airtight Opus1, Boulder, AQ Wel&Wild, SRA Scuttle Rack, BlueSound+LPS, Thorens 124DD+124SPU, Sennheiser, Metaxas R2R
  • haimoc
    haimoc Posts: 1,031
    edited December 2006
    The Plinius looks so cool. I hope I can have one sometimes. What a great student life that you have! I remembered my poor student time.
  • zombie boy 2000
    zombie boy 2000 Posts: 6,641
    edited December 2006
    No lie Haimoc....
    I seem to remember me and a boombox making sweet magic together.

    Excellent write-up Joey! Love to hear your ear on your gear whenever possible. It's cool to hear that the Axioms could at least compete in many respects.
    I never had it like this where I grew up. But I send my kids here because the fact is you go to one of the best schools in the country: Rushmore. Now, for some of you it doesn't matter. You were born rich and you're going to stay rich. But here's my advice to the rest of you: Take dead aim on the rich boys. Get them in the crosshairs and take them down. Just remember, they can buy anything but they can't buy backbone. Don't let them forget it. Thank you.Herman Blume - Rushmore
  • Joey_V
    Joey_V Posts: 8,552
    edited December 2006
    ZB,

    I just recently did a 2day long A/B comparison between the Cary SLP-98 and the Rogue 99 reference tube preamps... will put that up shortly over the weekend. :)

    Rest of y'all,

    Enjoy the read, guys!

    Joey
    Magico M2, JL113v2x2, EMM, ARC Ref 10 Line, ARC Ref 10 Phono, VPIx2, Lyra Etna, Airtight Opus1, Boulder, AQ Wel&Wild, SRA Scuttle Rack, BlueSound+LPS, Thorens 124DD+124SPU, Sennheiser, Metaxas R2R
  • mldennison
    mldennison Posts: 307
    edited December 2006
    very nice write-up. i will have to check axiom out, never heard them before.

    as for your setup, i can only imagine what things will sound like when you get out of that dorm room!
  • markmarc
    markmarc Posts: 2,309
    edited December 2006
    Great to see college students interested in audio!!! Out of curiousity, how many hours do the Strata Mini's have on them?
    Review Site_ (((AudioPursuit)))
    Founder/Publisher Affordable$$Audio 2006-13.
    Former Staff Member TONEAudio
    2 Ch. System
    Amplifiers: Parasound Halo P6 pre, Vista Audio i34, Peachtree amp500, Adcom GFP-565 GFA-535ii, 545ii, 555ii
    Digital: SimAudio HAD230 DAC, iMac 20in/Amarra,
    Speakers: Paradigm Performa F75, Magnepan .7, Totem Model 1's, ACI Emerald XL, Celestion Si Stands. Totem Dreamcatcher sub
    Analog: Technics SL-J2 w/Pickering 3000D, SimAudio LP5.3 phono pre
    Cable/Wires: Cardas, AudioArt, Shunyata Venom 3
  • Joey_V
    Joey_V Posts: 8,552
    edited December 2006
    markmarc wrote:
    Great to see college students interested in audio!!! Out of curiousity, how many hours do the Strata Mini's have on them?

    The Strata probably has 150 hours on them now...

    Joey :)
    Magico M2, JL113v2x2, EMM, ARC Ref 10 Line, ARC Ref 10 Phono, VPIx2, Lyra Etna, Airtight Opus1, Boulder, AQ Wel&Wild, SRA Scuttle Rack, BlueSound+LPS, Thorens 124DD+124SPU, Sennheiser, Metaxas R2R
  • Shizelbs
    Shizelbs Posts: 7,433
    edited December 2006
    Great review Joey. Sounds like you had a nice evening.
  • Joey_V
    Joey_V Posts: 8,552
    edited December 2006
    Zero wrote:
    Cool write-up Joey. We need to get some seasoned audiophiles in there... take ya down a few notches... :p

    Enjoy the music..!

    HAH!

    This guy had experience my friend.... Energy Veritas, Monitor Audios, Axioms, Wilsons, Von Schweikerts, Linn, Goldmund... truly seasoned. Into headphones with Grados, Sennheisers, and a plethora of headphone dedicated amplifications. Tube rolling... the works.

    He is a newly graduated Lawyer. So I told him not to sue me for malpractice when I'm done... he told me that he's got my back in the court of law! :)

    Joey
    Magico M2, JL113v2x2, EMM, ARC Ref 10 Line, ARC Ref 10 Phono, VPIx2, Lyra Etna, Airtight Opus1, Boulder, AQ Wel&Wild, SRA Scuttle Rack, BlueSound+LPS, Thorens 124DD+124SPU, Sennheiser, Metaxas R2R
  • RuSsMaN
    RuSsMaN Posts: 17,987
    edited December 2006
    That room HAS to be horrible, no? It looks so hostile, sound wise.

    Cool review, I gotta take it with a grain of salt though, someone that has been 'happy' with those little Axioms - I would think pretty much anything would 'blow his mind'.

    Cheers,
    Russ
    Check your lips at the door woman. Shake your hips like battleships. Yeah, all the white girls trip when I sing at Sunday service.
  • TroyD
    TroyD Posts: 13,077
    edited December 2006
    RuSsMaN wrote:
    That room HAS to be horrible, no? It looks so hostile, sound wise.

    I was sorta thinking the same thing....

    cool review.

    BDT
    I plan for the future. - F1Nut
  • Joey_V
    Joey_V Posts: 8,552
    edited December 2006
    TroyD wrote:
    I was sorta thinking the same thing....

    cool review.

    BDT

    He had Energy Veritas I believe while he was in a different state, but when he got married, he had to move and get rid of his large reference speakers... law school took a lot out of his audio budget and he settled for the Axioms. Did he like it? It was alright to him.

    First thing he told me when I picked him up was that he didnt think the Axioms were anything special to begin with.

    And yes... the room could use some work... but then again, I'm still in college so cut me some slack here. :p
    Magico M2, JL113v2x2, EMM, ARC Ref 10 Line, ARC Ref 10 Phono, VPIx2, Lyra Etna, Airtight Opus1, Boulder, AQ Wel&Wild, SRA Scuttle Rack, BlueSound+LPS, Thorens 124DD+124SPU, Sennheiser, Metaxas R2R
  • Joey_V
    Joey_V Posts: 8,552
    edited December 2006
    Zero wrote:
    Joey,

    You should have kept his career out of it! So much for credibility! hah! And didnt he just hear some of this gear at the dealer, vice actually owning it? I can't imagine an owner of Wilson speakers coming over with Axioms in hand (then again, theres always the **** and giggles thing).

    Sean,

    I'm not going out on a limb to assume how much this guy actually/really knows with regards to audio, but remember that the gear you own does not dictate how critical you are.

    Take yourself for example, though you dont own speakers that are $10K, wouldnt you say that you are just as critical or even moreso than someone with $10K speakers (me, perhaps)? Isnt that within the realm of possibility?

    Thing is, I was with this guy... and I can tell if someone is critical or not... and this guy was VERY critical. In my talks with you on the phone, I would say this guy is more critical than me or maybe even you. To tell you the truth, I was actually nervous when I plugged the Summits in. He is building up his system from the ground up and he was looking at a CDP at Glenn Poor, I didnt even know the name of it, but it was about $6.5K. He's about to explode in terms of cashflow and he's putting together a serious system. I think he wanted to listen to the Minis because of all the talk about it being a $6K speaker in terms of quality.... he probably just wanted to test it against his barometer of sound. I'm not sure exactly what he thought of the Minis in the end (whether he was going to buy a pair or audition other product... though he did mention Dali Euphonias quite a bit when he was over.. :confused: )... I merely stopped him between each song (a/b) and wrote down his responses.

    I had 2 other local audiophiles come by and both were very very impressed by the ML Summits.... the Minis were next to them and were demoed as well. One time, the LSi9 was right next to the other 2.

    Mark Schifter, CEO of AV123, is wanting to come by to my place to listen to the Minis next to the Summits. I'm having dinner with him at a Chicago steakhouse tomorrow pm.

    Sean... I'll tell MLS to give you a call! :)

    Anyway, the system is going good... looking to get a rack for the gear from the gf for Christmas.. and perhaps a move towards a PSaudio PowerPlant AC regenerator for early next year.

    Thanks guys!

    Joey
    Magico M2, JL113v2x2, EMM, ARC Ref 10 Line, ARC Ref 10 Phono, VPIx2, Lyra Etna, Airtight Opus1, Boulder, AQ Wel&Wild, SRA Scuttle Rack, BlueSound+LPS, Thorens 124DD+124SPU, Sennheiser, Metaxas R2R
  • VR3
    VR3 Posts: 28,643
    edited December 2006
    Until Axiom starts using something that isnt weighed in ounces, Ill take them as a company more seriously...

    Very cool review, its cool to find someone who likes your rig!
    - Not Tom ::::::: Any system can play Diana Krall. Only the best can play Limp Bizkit.
  • Joey_V
    Joey_V Posts: 8,552
    edited December 2006
    Until Axiom starts using something that isnt weighed in ounces, Ill take them as a company more seriously...

    Very cool review, its cool to find someone who likes your rig!
    Trey,

    You know me.. and you know what I think of the build. It's not too great.

    But, the sound was ok for what it was. For $300, it was clean and clear. Clinical and sterile, I thought. Not the most open sound, boxy at times, but you get good sound in the end.

    Joey ;)
    Magico M2, JL113v2x2, EMM, ARC Ref 10 Line, ARC Ref 10 Phono, VPIx2, Lyra Etna, Airtight Opus1, Boulder, AQ Wel&Wild, SRA Scuttle Rack, BlueSound+LPS, Thorens 124DD+124SPU, Sennheiser, Metaxas R2R
  • Joey_V
    Joey_V Posts: 8,552
    edited December 2006
    Zero wrote:
    Joey,

    My little Asian friend, amongst the entire forum, you should be the most astute to when I am trolling to pull a leg. Regardless, there is a hidden point instilled in there. I’m not going to tell you what it is. You’ll find it.

    Most musicians and audiophiles have a yardstick they use to measure tone and sound. Any veteran of sound is by nature, critical – carrying along with them their own guidelines and measurements. This said individuals backround is none of my concern. Just think, and you'll figure out what I am referring to..

    Enjoy the steak tomorrow with the big guy – and thanks for giving him the reminder!
    I knew what you were up to the whole time Sean... I just wasnt sure if the rest of the forum knew what we were up to.

    Dang man.. I was going to call you tonight, but I think it's too late for little Sean... bedtime for the little guy! I'll ring you tomorrow after the MLS dinner. :D

    Joey
    Magico M2, JL113v2x2, EMM, ARC Ref 10 Line, ARC Ref 10 Phono, VPIx2, Lyra Etna, Airtight Opus1, Boulder, AQ Wel&Wild, SRA Scuttle Rack, BlueSound+LPS, Thorens 124DD+124SPU, Sennheiser, Metaxas R2R
  • sucks2beme
    sucks2beme Posts: 5,601
    edited December 2006
    If the guy has good headphones, he listens to a lot of detail. You trade off detail for soundstage when going to speakers, unless you've got a pretty good budget.
    Other than the Head-fi guy with the "audio rock" on his head, most of
    those guys can pick out better sounding gear from the pack. As always,
    budget and available "demo" gear are the limiting factors.
    I'm happy you were able to help the guy pick out some speakers. It's so
    hard to find places to listen and truly compare stuff.
    "The legitimate powers of government extend to such acts only as are injurious to others. But it does me no injury for my neighbour to say there are twenty gods, or no god. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg." --Thomas Jefferson
  • Joey_V
    Joey_V Posts: 8,552
    edited December 2006
    sucks2beme wrote:
    If the guy has good headphones, he listens to a lot of detail. You trade off detail for soundstage when going to speakers, unless you've got a pretty good budget.
    Other than the Head-fi guy with the "audio rock" on his head, most of
    those guys can pick out better sounding gear from the pack. As always,
    budget and available "demo" gear are the limiting factors.
    I'm happy you were able to help the guy pick out some speakers. It's so
    hard to find places to listen and truly compare stuff.
    I agree man.... he listens and listens good. I will second your comment about how difficult it is to compare two speakers. Truly tough to get two speakers of interest into the same room.
    Zero wrote:
    Joey,

    Let the forum guess.. it keeps things interesting! Yep, I've been signing out at an earlier hour lately - I've already missed a few late night calls.

    Look forward to talking with you tomorrow. My toys are arriving today.. woot woot..

    Geez Sean... more toys?!?! How will I ever keep up with, Mr. Big Spender??

    Joey
    Magico M2, JL113v2x2, EMM, ARC Ref 10 Line, ARC Ref 10 Phono, VPIx2, Lyra Etna, Airtight Opus1, Boulder, AQ Wel&Wild, SRA Scuttle Rack, BlueSound+LPS, Thorens 124DD+124SPU, Sennheiser, Metaxas R2R