Is tilting SDAs a NO-NO?

Options
Larry Chanin
Larry Chanin Posts: 601
edited August 2004 in Speakers
Hi All,

I'm in the process of completing my home theater. (Please refer to the concept drawings link in my signature.) I've decided to stack CRS+ for my center channel, tilting the upper down and lower up so that they project a sonic image that is vertically centered on the screen.

This got me thinking that I should raise my SDA-1Cs, which I'm using as mains, so that their tweeters are vertically centered on the screen as well. Someone suggested if I raised the main's tweeters above ear level that I should tilt the speakers down toward the listeners.

Ordinarily this would make sense, however I'm concerned about two things:
  1. Will tilting SDAs hurt the SDA effect?
  2. How would I tilt an SDA-1C safetly without having them topple over?

Anyone know whether tilting SDAs would hurt interaural crosstalk cancellation?

Any ideas how to tilt an SDA without causing a major accident?

Thanks.

Larry

Comments

  • nadams
    nadams Posts: 5,877
    edited August 2004
    Options
    The SDA's were not meant to be tilted from the "SDA" standpoint.

    The only way to safely do it would be to put them on a box with a tilted top, and then affix a chain or bar or something that goes between the speaker and the wall it is against. But really, they aren't meant to be tilted.
    Ludicrous gibs!
  • dorokusai
    dorokusai Posts: 25,661
    edited August 2004
    Options
    1. IMO, Yes.
    2. Rubber doorstops.
    CTC BBQ Amplifier, Sonic Frontiers Line3 Pre-Amplifier and Wadia 581 SACD player. Speakers? Always changing but for now, Mission Argonauts I picked up for $50 bucks, mint.
  • Larry Chanin
    Larry Chanin Posts: 601
    edited August 2004
    Options
    Thanks Guys for the prompt responses,

    I wanted a good excuse not to tilt them. ;)

    How about raising the tweeters above ear level to center them on the screen? Do you think that is advisable?

    I should point out that this would make the tweeters about the level of the ears on the second row of seating, but obviously more than a foot over the ears in the first row of seating.

    Thanks.

    Larry
  • dorokusai
    dorokusai Posts: 25,661
    edited August 2004
    Options
    If it's strictly for HT, I wouldn't worry two shakes about it. HT doesn't require pinpoint placement. SDA's in the HT enviroment "work" but don't expect 2CH critical listening to ever be the same.
    CTC BBQ Amplifier, Sonic Frontiers Line3 Pre-Amplifier and Wadia 581 SACD player. Speakers? Always changing but for now, Mission Argonauts I picked up for $50 bucks, mint.
  • Larry Chanin
    Larry Chanin Posts: 601
    edited August 2004
    Options
    Hi Mark,

    Do you mean don't worry about any problems about raising them for home theater, or for home theater don't worry about (i.e., don't bother) centering them on the screen?

    With regard to critical two-channel listening, the acoustics in the room have been designed for multi-channel listening. That is the room is acoustically pretty dead. An acoustically dead environment wouldn't really support critical two channel listening since it requires a much more lively room for proper presentation.

    Larry
  • Emlyn
    Emlyn Posts: 4,920
    edited August 2004
    Options
    I have a pair of SDA-2As in a room where I'm usually standing rather than sitting, so I prop the front of the speakers up equally about 10 degrees to direct the sound higher than normally possible. It improves the sound quality where I usually stand quite substantially. I also have the speakers placed on amp stands to raise them up a few inches and decouple them from a carpeted floor. The SDA-1Cs are very front heavy, so I think Doro's idea of rubber door stops would work well. I just tried tilting mine backward and they'll go pretty far before their center of gravity is overcome.
  • amulford
    amulford Posts: 5,020
    edited August 2004
    Options
    Larry,

    I wouldn't worry about center pointing the centers. The front soundstage will be more or less flooded.

    What you need to concern is that panning will be correct. If you want to try and use SDA for actual sound placement, IMHO, I wouldn't worry about a center channel. The mains in phantom would do a better job. I think the centers would disrupt the effect. But that is just my opinion..

    As far as elevating the tweeters, I think it would just elevate the soundstage. No harmful effects, per say.

    Just my .02

    Anthony
  • Larry Chanin
    Larry Chanin Posts: 601
    edited August 2004
    Options
    Hi Anthony,

    Thanks for the response.

    I recently purchased a set of CRS+s because my CS400i wasn't a close enough timbre match to my SDA-1Cs while the CRS+s have exactly the same drivers. Since they obviously come in pairs I thought that stacking them would be less problematic that a side-by-side arrangement, and had the added advantage of being able to vertically center a sonic image on a large screen. A number of Polk Club members seemed to favor a dual approach as well so I thought I'd give it a try.

    Since I began researching dual centers I find the subject to be somewhat controversial, however I've made arrangements to mount both center speakers and I'll try it both ways and see for myself.

    With regard to your suggestion to eliminate the center all together, I agree that in critical two channel listening that may be preferred. However, for home theater applications the absence of a physical center channel would erroneously move the sounds to the closest speaker for those listeners seated off-axis. I should have mentioned that it is not my intent to use the CRS+s as SDA speakers. If I'm feeling adventureous I might wire the dimensional drivers in parallel with the stereo drivers.

    With regard to the mains, I'm thinking that I can experiment there as well. I think the easiest and perhaps most suitable way to elevate them would be to sit them on concrete block, perhaps one or two rows high.

    Thanks.

    Larry
  • HBombToo
    HBombToo Posts: 5,256
    edited August 2004
    Options
    I view the speaker position in my room much like I view the deployment of an antenna in uWave through any wireless application. Line of site is KEY!

    A speaker has a verticle and horizontal pattern and the sweet spot is the connection of the main beam of all radiators. The SDA effect is an add on to the stereo image so if you set it up much the same as a solid 2 channel application all is good while adding on the SDA effect. Uptilt and Downtilt principals should be the same in any situation. The part I can't overcome is the bass response as far as toe in... but then again if you are running a sub all should be good if in phase.

    This is of course my opinion from a common sense standpoint.

    Henry
    ***WAREMTAE***
  • madmax
    madmax Posts: 12,434
    edited August 2004
    Options
    What I notice about SDA's is that the image is higher than the speakers anyway. Actually it seems that where ever you focus your eyes (verically) seems to be where the sound is coming from. Of course left to right is a differnt story.
    madmax
    Vinyl, the final frontier...

    Avantgarde horns, 300b tubes, thats the kinda crap I want... :D
  • Larry Chanin
    Larry Chanin Posts: 601
    edited August 2004
    Options
    Originally posted by HBombToo
    The part I can't overcome is the bass response as far as toe in... but then again if you are running a sub all should be good if in phase.

    Hi Henry,

    Thanks for the response.

    I'm not sure I understand your comment regarding toe in. Are you suggesting that it's okay to toe in SDAs?

    Larry
  • Larry Chanin
    Larry Chanin Posts: 601
    edited August 2004
    Options
    Originally posted by Emlyn
    I have a pair of SDA-2As in a room where I'm usually standing rather than sitting, so I prop the front of the speakers up equally about 10 degrees to direct the sound higher than normally possible. It improves the sound quality where I usually stand quite substantially. I also have the speakers placed on amp stands to raise them up a few inches and decouple them from a carpeted floor. The SDA-1Cs are very front heavy, so I think Doro's idea of rubber door stops would work well. I just tried tilting mine backward and they'll go pretty far before their center of gravity is overcome.

    Hi Emlyn,

    Thanks for the response. My appologies, somehow I managed to miss it at first.

    Mark's suggestion regarding rubber door stops is an other low cost tweak that I can experiment with, especially since you've had good success with tilting. My initial concern was that the tilt might have to be more pronounced and would jeapordize the safety of the speaker without some elaborate device to couple it to the front wall.

    Larry
  • HBombToo
    HBombToo Posts: 5,256
    edited August 2004
    Options
    Originally posted by Larry Chanin
    Hi Henry,

    Thanks for the response.

    I'm not sure I understand your comment regarding toe in. Are you suggesting that it's okay to toe in SDAs?

    Larry

    I realize its against all religions but I have experimented with it and found SDA reacts much the same as all regular speakers.

    I bought my first pair of 2B's and thought something was wrong because of a bass vibration. Upon advice from some very knowledgeble members I removed the passive woofers looking for a dislocation but found none. As I played with position I noticed I could control this issue and can tell you the clarity from the high through the low and the SDA effect is SOLID.

    Its all about the room imo

    Henry
    ***WAREMTAE***
  • dorokusai
    dorokusai Posts: 25,661
    edited August 2004
    Options
    Originally posted by Larry Chanin
    Hi Mark,

    Do you mean don't worry about any problems about raising them for home theater, or for home theater don't worry about (i.e., don't bother) centering them on the screen?

    With regard to critical two-channel listening, the acoustics in the room have been designed for multi-channel listening. That is the room is acoustically pretty dead. An acoustically dead environment wouldn't really support critical two channel listening since it requires a much more lively room for proper presentation.

    Larry

    Yes, go with what works best for your area, screw SDA recommendations. None of the very best SDA setups I have heard are by the book....although NONE of them were toe-in or out.

    The SDA will as mentioned by Anthony, fill a large area easily.

    Rubber doorstops won't tilt them enough to be dangerous IMO. If you are concerned even after the "tilt", than pop out the PR and drop a 25lb. flat weight(Weightlifting type) in the bottom. It won't hurt anything. You could wrap it in a pillow case or even Dynamat it to make sure it doesn't "ring".
    CTC BBQ Amplifier, Sonic Frontiers Line3 Pre-Amplifier and Wadia 581 SACD player. Speakers? Always changing but for now, Mission Argonauts I picked up for $50 bucks, mint.
  • Larry Chanin
    Larry Chanin Posts: 601
    edited August 2004
    Options
    Originally posted by dorokusai
    Yes, go with what works best for your area, screw SDA recommendations. None of the very best SDA setups I have heard are by the book....although NONE of them were toe-in or out.

    Hi Mark,

    Thanks. I think Henry had it right, it does go against my religion to toe in SDAs. ;) But, I think I'll experiment with the other placement options, including the rubber door stop tilt.

    The SDA will as mentioned by Anthony, fill a large area easily.

    Agreed, the SDA mains will fill the area, but as I alluded to in my response, they can't correctly anchor movie dialog for members of the audience seated off-axis.

    Larry
  • dorokusai
    dorokusai Posts: 25,661
    edited August 2004
    Options
    You only have SDA to blame for that.
    CTC BBQ Amplifier, Sonic Frontiers Line3 Pre-Amplifier and Wadia 581 SACD player. Speakers? Always changing but for now, Mission Argonauts I picked up for $50 bucks, mint.