Streaming Video: Netflix vs. Hulu Plus vs. Amazon Instant ect.

falconcry72

I just got a new HDTV, so now I'm getting more into video including streaming video. My priority is HD and real 5.1 audio, which seems hard to find. Here's what I've found, but I'm new at this:

- Netflix: good amount of HD, limited 5.1 (Dolby Digital Plus, which I think is just a lower quality DD)

- Hulu Plus: Lots of HD, no 5.1 (dumb)

- Amazon instant: HD, some 5.1 (not sure of the format)

Are there video/audio quality differences between these? Are there other good streaming video sources I'm missing here?

In my HT setup, I have a HTPC with a good video card that supports 1080p and the lossless surround formats via HDMI, so I can access these services either through the PC or through the TV's own interface. I like going through the PC because it's easier to scroll through the service's options with a mouse and keyboard than with a remote. One annoyance is that Netflix doesn't offer as much HD content for access by PC's as they do for access by TV's. I don't understand why.

All help is appreciated! Super newb here!

drselect

I recently reactivated my Netflix account to compare it to Amazon Prime. I am not using them in my main HT system so I can't comment about sound Qaulity but as far as Picture quality goes I have not seen a difference. From my observation to date the biggest difference is in the UI. I prefer the Netflix over Amazon. However, for some reason I seem to have streaming issues with Netflix. The last movie I tried watching had constant loading issues and would pause sometimes for several minutes. It got so bad that I just stopped watching the movie. This has been a regular issue I have with Netflix sometime worse than others. I have never had this issue with Amazon. I am using the same sony BDP and Panasonic Plasma tv so I am not sure what is causing the issue. Also I have not found a big difference in content between Netflix and Amazon. Based on my current experience I will be dropping Netflix again and wait to see what Redbox/Verizon have to offer with their streaming.

falconcry72

drselect wrote: »

I recently reactivated my Netflix account to compare it to Amazon Prime. I am not using them in my main HT system so I can't comment about sound Qaulity but as far as Picture quality goes I have not seen a difference. From my observation to date the biggest difference is in the UI. I prefer the Netflix over Amazon. However, for some reason I seem to have streaming issues with Netflix. The last movie I tried watching had constant loading issues and would pause sometimes for several minutes. It got so bad that I just stopped watching the movie. This has been a regular issue I have with Netflix sometime worse than others. I have never had this issue with Amazon. I am using the same sony BDP and Panasonic Plasma tv so I am not sure what is causing the issue. Also I have not found a big difference in content between Netflix and Amazon. Based on my current experience I will be dropping Netflix again and wait to see what Redbox/Verizon have to offer with their streaming.

cool, good info. Thanks, Doc!

I signed up for netflix and hulu trials, I'll do amazon too and just see for myself.

The no 5.1 for hulu is probably a dealbreaker for me. I'm an audiophile first and foremost; video is just an affair.

leroyjr1

I've found that Netflix on the PS3 yields the best PQ of them all. Netflix on my oppo 103 isn't as good. If I want the best PQ I'll just toss in a Bluray. Can't wait to the 4k stuff to hit the market.

leroyjr1

Do you VT50 a favor and get a oppo. Running one on my Panny VT and the picture is stunning.

falconcry72

leroyjr1 wrote: »

Do you VT50 a favor and get a oppo. Running one on my Panny VT and the picture is stunning.

I think that will be the next upgrade!

I was able to sign up for the rebox/verizon streaming trial for a month. I will report back.

https://www.redboxinstant.com/

mrbigbluelight

Tried Hulu Plus (free 30 day trial with a Geico code) and cancelled after 1 week. One word: COMMERCIALS.

We've never had any "loading" problems with streaming Netflix. Had just a very few with Hulu Plus, no significant difference there. But .... did I mention the amount of COMMERCIALS on Hulu Plus ? Wouldn't matter to me if everything was HD, 5.1 and free, I still couldn't tolerate Hulu Plus.

leroyjr1

falconcry72 wrote: »

I think that will be the next upgrade!

I was able to sign up for the rebox/verizon streaming trial for a month. I will report back.

https://www.redboxinstant.com/

The 4 free monthly redbox rentals are a plus but the movies suck. Hopefully they'll add more down the road. I'll be canceling mine when the30 day free trial is over.

Tbone289

I use Netflix streaming through an HTPC. I mostly watch older TV shows that I've missed (24, Breaking Bad, etc.), and I've run across very few that were Dolby Digital encoded. This may not be the case for movies, but what I watch is mostly Prologic encoded. I prefer to rent Blu-Rays from Netflix for movie watching.

treitz3

Hello, falconcry72. With regards to Netflix streaming issues, it may just boil down to your gear and the compatibility with Netflix itself. Let it be first understood that I am in no way saying that you have inferior gear. I'm just relaying my experience with regards to Netflix and the streaming issues you speak of.

I tried Netflix streaming on two different devices and the wife and I got constantly frustrated with the buffering times and constant pausing of the movies/programming material. Sometimes to the point to where, as drselect mentioned, we would just stop watching the movie altogether. We figured that it was a bandwidth demand problem so we started watching late at night or at non-peak demand times. No freakin' difference. The same thing would happen on both devices at all times of the day or night with absolutely no rhyme or reason to it or real explanation as to why it was happening in the first place. We even upgraded our Wi-fi to help eliminate the issue which ended up proving futile. When Netflix ended up raising the rates, we just cancelled altogether and I wrote them off.

Fast forward a couple of months and we get a new Samsung HDTV and associated DTV satellite gear. As I'm researching how to optimize the the TV, I run across an article about Netflix lowering their rates so I decided to give them one more chance. Since the Samsung is a "Smart TV" [whatever that means] and can access Netflix through the TV, I figured what the hell. We'll try it. To be honest, I was expecting the same exact issues and went into the whole thing with a preconceived notion and an extreme negative expectation bias.

Well, it's probably been a year since that time and I can honestly say that the wife and I talked about this very topic a couple of weeks back. One of the things mentioned in our conversation was the amount of pauses we have had to take, how many times programming stopped with regards to Netflix and it turned out that she has only experienced it once and same with myself. I have only experienced it once as well during this time. That's a far cry from our initial experience with Netflix. So, with that said....I have no idea what to recommend or where one would even begin to address issues with streaming Netflix but I thought I'd at the very least share with you my own experience. It may just boil down to a compatibility issue as nothing else changed and I don't believe that it was just a coincidence that when we purchased the TV that Netflix's streaming issues all of a sudden stopped.

DTV also has a streaming thing going and it's hooked up but ever since Netflix stared working with no issues, we haven't even tried it yet. Over time, I think we have tried Hulu once or twice. Obviously our experience wasn't preffered with that. The only other thing I'd like to comment on is that after Netflix's price increase and subsequent reduction, the selection has dropped considerably.

I have no comment on the multi-channel thing as I am strictly a 2-channel guy.

Tom

zingo

I have all three video services steamed through blu-ray player or smart TV, and I feel that Hulu Plus has the best video quality. When bandwidth is adequate, it is very high quality HD. All three services obviously are very dependent on internet speeds (+3kbps), and I don't suggest WIFI for streaming audio or video.

I only use a two channel system, but NetFlix movies usually sound pretty decent on it.

falconcry72

treitz3 wrote: »

Hello, falconcry72. With regards to Netflix streaming issues, it may just boil down to your gear and the compatibility with Netflix itself. Let it be first understood that I am in no way saying that you have inferior gear. I'm just relaying my experience with regards to Netflix and the streaming issues you speak of.

I tried Netflix streaming on two different devices and the wife and I got constantly frustrated with the buffering times and constant pausing of the movies/programming material. Sometimes to the point to where, as drselect mentioned, we would just stop watching the movie altogether. We figured that it was a bandwidth demand problem so we started watching late at night or at non-peak demand times. No freakin' difference. The same thing would happen on both devices at all times of the day or night with absolutely no rhyme or reason to it or real explanation as to why it was happening in the first place. We even upgraded our Wi-fi to help eliminate the issue which ended up proving futile. When Netflix ended up raising the rates, we just cancelled altogether and I wrote them off.

Fast forward a couple of months and we get a new Samsung HDTV and associated DTV satellite gear. As I'm researching how to optimize the the TV, I run across an article about Netflix lowering their rates so I decided to give them one more chance. Since the Samsung is a "Smart TV" [whatever that means] and can access Netflix through the TV, I figured what the hell. We'll try it. To be honest, I was expecting the same exact issues and went into the whole thing with a preconceived notion and an extreme negative expectation bias.

Well, it's probably been a year since that time and I can honestly say that the wife and I talked about this very topic a couple of weeks back. One of the things mentioned in our conversation was the amount of pauses we have had to take, how many times programming stopped with regards to Netflix and it turned out that she has only experienced it once and same with myself. I have only experienced it once as well during this time. That's a far cry from our initial experience with Netflix. So, with that said....I have no idea what to recommend or where one would even begin to address issues with streaming Netflix but I thought I'd at the very least share with you my own experience. It may just boil down to a compatibility issue as nothing else changed and I don't believe that it was just a coincidence that when we purchased the TV that Netflix's streaming issues all of a sudden stopped.

DTV also has a streaming thing going and it's hooked up but ever since Netflix stared working with no issues, we haven't even tried it yet. Over time, I think we have tried Hulu once or twice. Obviously our experience wasn't preffered with that. The only other thing I'd like to comment on is that after Netflix's price increase and subsequent reduction, the selection has dropped considerably.

I have no comment on the multi-channel thing as I am strictly a 2-channel guy.

Tom

dude... I never said I was having buffering problems with netflix. lol.

I'm just trying to figure out the best places to stream real 5.1 channel audio and HD video.

Thanks for the input!

falconcry72

zingo wrote: »

I have all three video services steamed through blu-ray player or smart TV, and I feel that Hulu Plus has the best video quality. When bandwidth is adequate, it is very high quality HD. All three services obviously are very dependent on internet speeds (+3kbps), and I don't suggest WIFI for streaming audio or video.

I only use a two channel system, but NetFlix movies usually sound pretty decent on it.

Hulu's HD content does look pretty good... too bad they don't do 5.1.

treitz3

falconcry72 wrote: »

dude... I never said I was having buffering problems with netflix. lol.

No need to laugh. It's Friday and I'm just sitting at home relaxing. Some folks had mentioned that they had streaming issues and you had mentioned that...

falconcry72 wrote: »

All help is appreciated! Super newb here!

With that said, I think I'll slide out now...

Tom

philr168

I have both netflix and hulu. The commericals on hulu are annoying. As for picture quality it's hard to compare, netflix runs on a ps3 while hulu on a pc, the netflix is better but it's apples to oranges.

heiney9

I use a ROKU device to stream Netflix and have almost zero streaming/buffering issues. It can happen, but it's rare for me.

H9

P.S. Hope I didn't just jinx myself :frown:

hochpt21

Out of curiosity, I was just looking through the titles on Amazon for movies and am not impressed. Really, how about putting something worth watching on there. I mean, there are a few I would watch, but overall now worth paying for in my case.

hochpt21

I also think it's a great deal as a prime member, epecially with the free two day shipping and other perks.

I just meant looking through the movies that are included in the prime membership, there are not a lot of big titles. I was searching around a little more and it looks like you can digitally "rent" or "buy" pretty much anything, but it would be nice to have some good titles included in the membership.

I personally am a big fan of Amazon.

markmarc

I have Amazon Prime and my son (who is temporarily back home) has NetFlix. We tried them both out using my iPad. Amazon (free with Prime membership) was smoother regarding buffering with the wireless antennae at a great distance. With antennae close the Netflix has a sharper image and the advantage in that many more devices (bd players, Apple TV, etc.) displays it on a flat screen tv. I'm hoping that Amazon will follow HBO's iPad app and update it to HDMI out so I can enjoy it via the wireless connection thru Apple TV.

Mikey081057

I use Amazon (prime) if i really wanna see the movie, i order the blu ray. I tried hulu, but liked vudu's pic and audio quality better. i still tend to gravitate back to directv for movies tho...many are 1080p and vg 5.1 audio.

i just upgraded my dtv receiver to the Genie that they advertise the spit out of, and it is quite impressive.. record/watch up to 5 at once and whole house dvr. as a sports fan directv is a necessity, and they have great movie pkg... don't believe the stuff about dishes being inferior to cable,,, mine has been solid since 1997. no issues.