Installing Driver Support Rings on 5B's

heiney9

TOOLFORLIFEFAN (Larry) came up with a great solution for anchoring/securing the drivers in several vintage Polk models, mostly consisting of the SDA series. I had him make me a set for my Polk 5B's in addition to a set for my SDA 1C's. He engineered a series of metal rings that fit behind the driver cut outs inside the cabinets with threaded nipples that go through the current screw holes (after enlarging them a bit) and fit flush with the front baffle.

This way instead of using wood screws to secure the drivers to the baffle you use threaded bolts into the threaded nipples. This sandwiches the driver basket between the particle board baffle and the steel ring behind it. No more stripped out wood holes and a much more solid way to secure the drivers to the baffle.

Tools needed:

3 or 4 - 1" C-Clamps (most important tool)
Power drill
I used a 9/32 wood drill bit
Phillips screw driver
Torx bits
Box knife
Small flashlight
Vacuum cleaner
Small flat blade screw driver to remove the glue (as necessary)

I've had the rings for awhile and just needed to spend the time to install them. Larry provides templates which you simply secure in place with C-Clamps and then drill out the existing screw holes to accommodate the threaded nipples attached to the rings . The 5B's are smaller so I used 1" c-clamps and they worked perfectly. This was also intended to be a trial run before I jumped in and did my SDA 1C's. This turned out to be much simpler than I had thought. One area that some time needs to be spent on and is a bit of a PITA, is removing the glue inside the cabinet.

In both 5B's there were thick globs of glue around in the inside portion of the PR cut out. If you don't remove the excess glue the rings won't sit flush on the inside of the baffle. I used a small flash light sitting inside the cabinet, a box knife and a small flat blade screw driver to cut and chisel out the excess glue.

One other thing of note is for the MW driver and passive radiator you will probably want to use a washer between the bolt head and basket. The bolt heads are only slightly larger than the basket screw holes and if you don't use washers there is a good possibility the bolt head will "punch" through the basket hole. This is not an issue with the tweeters.

Another tip is once you start tightening the bolts, tighten them in a criss-cross pattern and evenly tighten all bolts. If you don't do it this way, it is very easy to distort the driver basket. Also I've found you don't have to tighten the screws down with an iron fist. Just snug them all down.

I had originally used Mortite in place of my disintegrating original gaskets. The Mortite was completely intact and was not messy at all you'll see in the photos it stayed right where it was supposed to be. Mortite works well and without any issues. Highly recommended.


You can see the rings and templates as well as the tweeter brackets (in the upper left)


All the drivers pulled and you can see how neat a tidy the Mortite is after about a year. No issues with it sticking or pulling away, etc.


Mortite works as intended.


Templates are in place ready to be secured by 1" C-clamps prior to drilling the holes.


Example of the glue issue I mentioned. It's a pain working in such a small area but luckily the glue comes undone pretty easily.


Tweeter bracket in place ready to drill. I drilled out the existing holes for all the drivers.




The bracket has a cut out like the template and to keep the tweeter bracket and driver ring from interfering with each other the ring needs to be installed with the cut facing upward.





It's really simple and straight forward. You need to remove the glue, and for the passive radiator rings Larry provides two scores in the rings where you will need to bend the ring slightly to get into the Passive radiator opening.

Much simpler than I thought. Some will want to use a drill stand to ensure a perfect perpendicular hole, but I just eyeballed it and had zero issues.

I think that covers it. I have just a few hours listening with the new rings, but I do notice some of the fixtures in my office rattle now with low bass notes where they didn't before. I do think there is increased bass that seems to be a tad firmer than before. But I need more time to evaluate other subtle changes.

H9

Toolfan66

Nice write up H9!!!!

cnh

So for those of us who are DIY and 'tool' challenged, let me see if I understand how many parts we have there?

Larry's rings seem, from the pics above, to be comprised of an 'outer' ring that mounts flush onto the front of the speaker baffle, and an inner link with screw hole protrusions that fit behind inside the cabinet and anchor the screw when it is tightened from outside once the two pieces are glued--one outside the other inside? Yes?

This provides a 'more' secure mounting and seal that won't strip the ordinary wood screw holes found in these and other speakers. Am I correct?

I also see some partial ring pieces above? I understand the inner and outer ring thing, I think...but what are the semi (quarter circle) pieces for?

cnh

agfrost

Nice writeup Brock; and thanks for a bit of motivation as I need to find some time to do the same with my 11TL's.

Looking at your pictures gave me a moment's pause as I didn't remember having a template for the tweeters, but I just ran downstairs and they're there with the rest. Need to investigate how the glue situation is with my RTAs, as every model seems to have different issues with glue and/or cabinet braces.

Jay

Edit: Did you reuse the Mortite, or did you revert to standard gasket material?

agfrost

cnh wrote: »

So for those of us who are DIY and 'tool' challenged, let me see if I understand how many parts we have there?

Larry's rings seem, from the pics above, to be comprised of an 'outer' ring that mounts flush onto the front of the speaker baffle, and an inner link with screw hole protrusions that fit behind inside the cabinet and anchor the screw when it is tightened from outside once the two pieces are glued--one outside the other inside? Yes?

This provides a 'more' secure mounting and seal that won't strip the ordinary wood screw holes found in these and other speakers. Am I correct?

I also see some partial ring pieces above? I understand the inner and outer ring thing, I think...but what are the semi (quarter circle) pieces for?

cnh

The "outer" ring you're seeing is the drill template, which is clamped in place for drilling through the baffle, then this ring is removed. The "inner" ring has the threads which are inserted through the new holes.

The "flat" tweeter piece is again a drilling template; the "partial" rings you're referring to are the tweeter rings, there are two per tweeter.

Outfitter03

H9 thanks for the write up and the pictures. This will make it much easier to proceed and I do need to get a few of the small clamps.

heiney9

cnh wrote: »

So for those of us who are DIY and 'tool' challenged, let me see if I understand how many parts we have there?

Larry's rings seem, from the pics above, to be comprised of an 'outer' ring that mounts flush onto the front of the speaker baffle, and an inner link with screw hole protrusions that fit behind inside the cabinet and anchor the screw when it is tightened from outside once the two pieces are glued--one outside the other inside? Yes?

This provides a 'more' secure mounting and seal that won't strip the ordinary wood screw holes found in these and other speakers. Am I correct?

I also see some partial ring pieces above? I understand the inner and outer ring thing, I think...but what are the semi (quarter circle) pieces for?

cnh

Sorry about that, many times I assume everyone knows and understands the minor details. Larry sent the rings, bolts/screws as well as templates to drill larger holes in the baffle. What you see in the photo clamped down are the drilling templates. The actual support rings go inside the cabinet *behind* the baffle cut outs. Approx 1/2" threaded nipples fit through the newly enlarged holes (from the back) and then a supplied threaded bolt secures the driver to the ring. The nipples are attached to the rings. In essence sandwiching the baffle between the driver and the newly installed circular metal ring.

The tweeter is done with the same concept, except rather than having a fully rectangular square support behind the tweeter he made a pair of curved brackets. One for the top and one for the bottom. IIRC, this was because of a space issue on the baffle of some models.

agfrost wrote: »

Nice writeup Brock; and thanks for a bit of motivation as I need to find some time to do the same with my 11TL's.

Looking at your pictures gave me a moment's pause as I didn't remember having a template for the tweeters, but I just ran downstairs and they're there with the rest. Need to investigate how the glue situation is with my RTAs, as every model seems to have different issues with glue and/or cabinet braces.

Jay

Edit: Did you reuse the Mortite, or did you revert to standard gasket material?

The Mortite was reused as it was sitting in exactly the same location as when I intalled it over a year ago. Fully intact. Perfect. Highly recommended.

H9

P.s. Also I didn't use glue to secure the ring inside the cabinet. They fit very snug and once you tighten everthing down, glue is not necessary, IMO.

heiney9

cnh wrote: »

I also see some partial ring pieces above? I understand the inner and outer ring thing, I think...but what are the semi (quarter circle) pieces for?

cnh

The "curved" parts you see are for the tweeters, (2) for each tweeter (top and bottom) the photo shows all the tweeter brackets for all my Polks. So in the photo the left overs are for my 1C's. Larry sent those all in one package so all those in the photo aren't just for the 5B's.

H9

cnh

Thanks Brock.

I really couldn't tell exactly what was happening in the process because all the pieces confused me..but then again, I probably shouldn't have dozed off in those shop classes in school? Suffice it to say that I'm 'not' all thumbs, but I'm not a big DIY guy either. But since I have both some SDAs and a set of Monitor 5As I may have to get off the sofa and actually 'do' something. lol

This thread is very useful in that sense!

cnh

heiney9

It's not difficult. Just takes some patience a few basic tools. Like I said the biggest PITA is removing the cabinet glue inside the cabinets. They were quite generous with it and you just need some patience to work in a small area completely blind.

Other steps I didn't show were removal of the fiberglass batting, vacuuming of the sawdust as well as being sure to cover the x-over with a towel. I opted not to remove the terminal cup from the cabinet. But one could do that, perhaps that might help a little if the glue was particularly difficult to reach. I got lucky and only a small portion of the glue was in my way.

H9

heiney9

So far I have noticed improved bass response and perhaps a bit of clarity in the midrange vocal area.

H9

headrott

Perhaps more clarity Brock?? I thought is was glaringly obvious the clarity improved, although I have not heard a pair of 5B's with the rings installed. Perhaps speaker model may affect the ring results??

Greg

F1nut

Pretty good step by step, Brock.

I'm going to add my $.02...

A butt style wood chisel will make any glue removal much easier. If one needs to remove any of the glue, you need to make sure the cabinet remains sealed.

VERY IMPORTANT.....the correct drill size is 9/32.

And last but not least, Mortite sucks!

Toolfan66

F1nut wrote: »

And last but not least, Mortite sucks!

hehe!!! I knew when I saw you posted here you would post that..:biggrin:

fbm211

I dont really care for the stuff myself.

heiney9

F1nut wrote: »

Pretty good step by step, Brock.

I'm going to add my $.02...

A butt style wood chisel will make any glue removal much easier. If one needs to remove any of the glue, you need to make sure the cabinet remains sealed.

VERY IMPORTANT.....the correct drill size is 9/32.

And last but not least, Mortite sucks!

The 9/16 bit worked without an issue everything is very snug, but if you say 9/32's is more correct then it's noted.

I happen to really think Mortite works great, easy to use, no mess, stays put, etc. To those reading this thread feel free to try whatever floats your boat. Experiment a little bit.

I agree, DO NOT just rip all the glue out. It's still needed to seal the cabinet so only cut and/or chisel away as little as needed to let the ring(s) sit flush with the baffle.

Greg, I honestly haven't put much time on them yet. It's Summer and listening sessions are few and far between, but I'll update after I get some good listening time in on them.

I was just glad I didn't "lose" the rings in the move. I packed them away and almost forgot where I put them. I've had all the rings since he first offered them. The 1C's will be more involved with dynamat and I'm installing spikes too. This was a good trial run just to get a lay of the project, so to speak.

H9

F1nut

Brock,

9/16 is 1/16 larger than 1/2". I know you didn't use a 9/16" drill bit otherwise you'd have huge holes in your cabinets.

I did experiment with the Mortite and found that the bass response was better with the stock gaskets. Addtionally, when one adds the rings the possible need of a better seal goes out the window. Hell, you could probably get away without using any kind of seal with the rings installed.

A suggestion for anyone wanting to try the Mortite. Do not apply the Mortite over the original gaskets. Carefully remove and save them.

heiney9

Jesse, I completely mis-typed it

I used a 9/32 drill bit

So to those looking at doing this don't use 9/16" drill bit

The correct bit is

9/32"

Maybe Mark or Russ or Ken can go back and edit my original post so someone doesn't screw up. THIS IS exactly why I wish we could edit!!

H9

F1nut

heiney9 wrote: »

THIS IS exactly why I wish we could edit!!

H9

Amen brother, amen!

txcoastal1

Great DIY thread guys....TY

Joe08867

Nice job Brock,

You say the bass is more responsive. In what way. Tighter? Forward?

dorokusai

heiney9 wrote: »

Jesse, I completely mis-typed it

I used a 9/32 drill bit

So to those looking at doing this don't use 9/16" drill bit

The correct bit is

9/32"

Maybe Mark or Russ or Ken can go back and edit my original post so someone doesn't screw up. THIS IS exactly why I wish we could edit!!

H9

I just happened to be reading and it's fixed. Don't hold your breath on the editing and always remember that your buddy(s) messed that up, not newbies.

Joe - My bass got tighter and more accurate, not more forward. Brock's experience may be different.

Joe08867

Thanks Doro, I was expecting a tighter response but didn't know if it changed any other characteristics of the low end. More accuracy is always a plus in my book.

heiney9

Thanks Mark, I realize that.....just frustrating sometimes, especially when a critical mistake is made for a DIY how to......

I hadn't gotten around to contacting you to edit for me, thanks again

Joe, I'll get back to you on the bass. It's definitely more up front and hits a little harder and deeper. Like I said I have fixtures in my office/computer room that rattle and vibrate, drawer handles, closet door tracks, etc that didn't before.

While it's still very early in the evaluation process and it is a new room since I just moved in May, etc......I'm not 100% convinced I like it. It's almost too much bass and at this point I'm not sure it blends or is as well integrated as it was prior to the rings. Could be a placement issue and room set-up now, but for me it seems a small part of the "magic" I had with this little office rig is diminished.

My big fear is if the same thing happens when I do the SDA 1C's. I have plenty of bass right now, I don't need more nor do I need it to be more prominent. The problem is the holes are drilled for the brackets and there's really no going back. I could fill in the holes and then turn the drivers a 1/4 turn and drill new stock screw holes, but honestly it needs a lot more evaluation and placement trials.

Again just my initial reaction........if it continues I may remove the Mortite and see if that helps.

H9

dorokusai

I never installed Mortite and just use the styrofoam gaskets with the rings.

Joe08867

That is what I am worried about with this upgrade. It sounds like the bass came forward. It is good for speakers that need the help but older SDA's and Monitor series are pretty good in that department.

I don't know if I planned on this upgrade or not but after the Sonic Barrier I am extremely pleased with my SDA's. So maybe I should leave well enough alone.

Also, Doro said the accuracy was better? What do you think? I know we seem to have similar taste in stuff so I am guessing you will think it is to pronounced and takes away from the smooth transition from the highs. That is only due to the fact that the bass seems to dominate in what you said earlier.

I will say after using sonic barrier I had to rethink placement. They needed to be closer to the wall than before. I would bet playing around with that will help.

PS not a fan of mortite. I prefer to use a gasket like material I bought from Michael's Arts and Crafts.

heiney9

UPDATE:

For Joe08867,

The bass hits harder and is more firm than before. My main issue was an overly warm dac that seemed to be fine before the rings, but then seemed a little too rounded after the rings. Changed dac's and the bass is excellent. My point, I don't think the rings contributed to my bass issues.

H9

Moose68Bash

I just want to say that every time I come across and read a new thread, especially of the DIY variety, I learn something.

From this thread: Don't try to remove all the hot glue inside the speaker cabinets, just the hot glue that impedes installation of Larry's rings.

Thanks for the very good and detailed description of your process, H9, and for all the very good discussion that followed. It makes things much easier for all of us who follow your lead.